ETF vs Mutual Fund vs Index Fund: What Is The Difference?
Confused between ETFs, mutual funds, and index funds? Learn the key differences and find out which investment suits your goals best.
2 Min read | Invest
ETF vs Mutual Fund vs Index Fund: Understanding Your Investment Options
Picture this... You've opened your first brokerage account and you're ready to start investing.
But then you see it: thousands of funds with confusing acronyms and overlapping names. ETFs, mutual funds, index funds: Which one do you pick?
Here's where it gets tricky. These aren't completely separate products. An index fund can either be a mutual fund or an ETF. That is the source of most confusion.
The U.S. investment landscape in 2025 is honestly incredible. Back in the 80's, if you put $1,000 into a typical fund, you might pay $20 or more every year just in fees, whether the fund made money or not. Now, thanks to the massive rise of ETFs and Index Funds, the price tag for investing has collapsed.
You can now invest in funds with annual management costs that are effectively zero percent. That's not a typo. Zero. Making this the best time in history to be an ordinary investor.
But the low-cost revolution only pays off if you pick the right vehicle.
In this article, we are going to present the main differences between ETFs, mutual funds, and index funds. We provide a comparison side by side which will help you make the best decision for your individual financial goals.
What Are ETFs, Mutual Funds, And Index Funds? Let's Go Deeper
What Is An ETF (Exchange-Traded Fund)?
An ETF is an investment fund that trades on stock exchanges just like individual stocks. You can buy or sell ETF shares all day long while the market is open.
Most ETFs track market indices like the S&P 500, the total U.S. stock market, or specific sectors like technology or healthcare. You can buy a single share for whatever it costs (often $50 to $300 depending on the fund), and many brokers now offer fractional shares, so you can invest with even less.
ETFs are also champions of tax efficiency! The ETF fund itself does not have to sell its underlying stocks (like the S&P 500 companies it holds) to give you cash. The cash comes from the new buyer in a process called "in-kind redemption". This is the entire secret: The ETF fund rarely sells its holdings for cash. It avoids creating the kind of taxable profit that gets passed on as a surprise tax bill to everyone else.
ETFs have absolutely exploded in popularity.
Assets in ETFs have surged past $10 trillion (that's $10,000,000,000,000!) in 2024. More importantly, we've seen record-breaking new money - over $1.1 trillion - poured into these funds in a single year. That kind of rapid growth tells you everything you need to know: investors have figured out that ETFs offer a powerful combination of low costs, tax efficiency, and flexibility.
What Is A Mutual Fund?
A mutual fund is a professionally managed investment pool where thousands of investors contribute money, and a fund manager uses that combined capital to buy stocks, bonds, or other securities according to the fund's stated strategy.
The big difference from ETFs: mutual funds trade only once per day, after the market closes. The fund company calculates the total value of all the fund's holdings divided by the number of shares outstanding. Everyone who places an order that day gets that closing price.
Mutual funds typically require minimum investments, often between $500 and $3,000. You buy and sell shares directly with the fund company, not on a stock exchange.
Mutual funds can be actively managed (where a professional tries to beat the market by picking winning stocks) or passively managed (where the fund simply tracks an index). The actively managed ones charge higher fees.
What Is An Index Fund?
Here's where it gets interesting: index funds aren't actually a separate category of investment. They're a management style that can be packaged as either an ETF or a mutual fund.
An index fund passively tracks a market index like the S&P 500, the total U.S. stock market, or international markets. Instead of paying a fund manager to actively pick stocks they think will outperform, index funds simply buy all (or a representative sample) of the securities in their target index. The goal isn't to beat the market. It's to match the market at the lowest possible cost.
Think of the Index Fund strategy as a powerful, efficient engine. That engine is the star, built for long-term performance. You can buy this winning engine packaged in two different vehicles (ETFs or Mutual Funds). Both vehicles have the exact same engine (the S&P 500 stocks) and will take you to the same destination with virtually the same speed.
The only differences are in the driver experience (trading flexibility) and tiny differences in costs and tax efficiency. The engine is the strategy; the vehicle is just the package.
ETF vs Mutual Fund vs Index Fund: Head-To-Head Comparison
Here is a table with a comparison overview at a glance.
| Feature | ETFs | Mutual Funds | Index Funds (ETF or Mutual Fund) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading | Real time pricing (9:30 AM to 4:00 PM ET) | Once daily (4:00 PM ET) | Depends on whether it is an ETF or Mutual Fund |
| Average Expense Ratio | Passive: 0.15% Active: 0.69% | Passive: 0.60% Active: 0.89% | 0.02% to 0.60% with zero-cost options available |
| Minimum Investment | No minimum | $500 to $3,000 with zero-cost options available | Depends on whether it is an ETF or Mutual Fund |
| Tax Efficiency | Highly efficient | Less efficient | Depends on whether it is an ETF or Mutual Fund |
| Management Style | Mostly passive | Mostly active | Always passive |
| Best For | Tax efficiency, low minimums, trading flexibility, frequent rebalancing | Automatic dollar-amount investing, 401(k) plans, systematic contributions | Long-term buy-and-hold investors, cost-conscious investors, core portfolio holdings |
Let's break down how these investment vehicles stack up across the factors that actually affect your returns and your experience as an investor.
Trading Flexibility And Pricing
ETFs
- Trade continuously throughout market hours. You can buy or sell any time the market is open, and you will get whatever the current market price is in that moment.
- You can use sophisticated order types like limit orders ("only buy if the price drops to $150"), stop-loss orders ("sell automatically if it drops below $140"), or even short sell ETFs if you think the market's heading down.
Mutual Funds
- Trade once daily at the NAV calculated after the 4:00 PM market close. Place your order anytime during the day, and you'll get that end-of-day price. No intraday trading, no limit orders, no real-time pricing.
Index Funds
- Dependant on whether you have invested in an ETF or Mutual Fund type, with the parameters mentioned above.
Costs And Expense Ratios
What is an Expense Ratio?
The Expense Ratio is the single most important cost. It is the annual fee the fund company charges to manage the fund, expressed as a percentage of the money you have invested. This cost is automatically taken out of the fund's assets - you never write a check, but it directly reduces your investment return.
Example: If a fund has a 0.10% expense ratio, you pay $1 per year for every $1,000 you have invested.
The simple truth is that neither ETFs nor Mutual Funds are inherently cheaper. You must check the specific cost of the fund you are looking at.
- Fidelity offers ZERO expense ratio funds (literally 0.00%) for several index mutual funds.
- Schwab's S&P 500 ETF charges as little as 0.02%.
- Vanguard's 500 Index Fund Admiral Shares charges around 0.04%.
Tax Efficiency
ETFs
- Use the "in-kind redemption" mechanism we mentioned earlier. When large investors want to redeem ETF shares, the fund gives them a basket of the actual stocks instead of cash. This means the ETF doesn't have to trigger capital gains. The result: ETFs rarely distribute capital gains to shareholders.
Mutual Funds
- When shareholders redeem their shares, the fund has to raise cash by selling securities. Those sales trigger capital gains, which get distributed to all remaining shareholders. Even if you didn't sell anything and your fund lost value that year, you might still owe taxes on capital gains distributions. It's frustrating and inefficient.
Index Funds
- Index mutual funds are better than active mutual funds on this front because they trade less frequently, generating fewer capital gains. But they still can't match the tax efficiency of ETFs.
Minimum Investment Requirements
ETFs
- Require only enough money to buy one share. If an ETF trades at $150 per share, that's your minimum. This matters most when you're starting out with limited capital.
- Many brokers now offer fractional shares, so you can invest $50 or even $10 in an ETF. There's effectively no minimum investment.
Mutual Funds
- Typically require $500 to $3,000 minimums.
- Vanguard requires $3,000 for most of their mutual funds, though they've lowered minimums to $1,000 for target-date retirement funds. Fidelity and Schwab have $0 minimums for many of their funds, which is fantastic.
Index Funds
- Dependant on whether you have invested in an ETF or Mutual Fund type, with the parameters mentioned above.
Management Style And Performance
Here, we have two options: Actively or Passively Managed Funds.
Both are available in ETF and Mutual Fund formats. Index Funds are by nature passively managed, as they track a specific market index.
So what do we go for? An actively managed fund, or a passively managed fund? Here's the data that matters:
- Only 42% of active funds beat their passive peers in 2024.
- Over 10 years, that success rate drops to 22%.
Let that sink in. If you pick an actively managed fund, you've got a 78% chance it will underperform a simple index fund over 10 years. Those aren't good odds, especially when you consider the higher fees active funds charge.
Accessibility
ETFs
- Trading: You can buy them through every major brokerage platform (eToro, TradeStation, etc.) and increasingly through popular, beginner-friendly apps like Revolut.
- Automatic Investing: Most platforms require you to buy a whole number of shares, or rely on a fractional share system that executes the trade at the market price when the order is placed.
Mutual Funds
- Trading: The fund company handles the trade and ensures every penny is invested. You can invest an exact fixed dollar amount every month without worrying about share prices or fractions. For investors who want to set up automatic monthly contributions and truly never think about it, mutual funds offer unmatched "set-it-and-forget-it" convenience.
- Automatic Reinvestment: Dividends and capital gais are automatically reinvested at the fund's Net Asset Value (NAV) without any extra fees or price fluctuations, making the process incredibly smooth for long-term compounding.
Index Funds
- Dependant on whether you have invested in an ETF or Mutual Fund type, with the parameters mentioned above.
FAQs
Which is better for beginners: ETF, mutual fund, or index fund?
Low-cost index funds in either ETF or mutual fund format are the ideal choice for beginners.
They are simple, require no stock-picking, and have the best long-term track record against expensive professional managers.
Are index funds safer than ETFs or mutual funds?
No. Whether a fund is structured as an ETF or a Mutual Fund has no impact on its safety or risk.
The risk of any fund comes entirely from the underlying holdings:
- An S&P 500 Index Fund carries the identical market risk whether it's an ETF or a mutual fund. If the S&P 500 index drops 20%, your investment drops roughly 20%.
- Index funds reduce single-stock risk through broad diversification (owning 500 companies is safer than owning one).
- No fund type is "safe" from market declines.
Can I lose money in ETFs, mutual funds, or index funds?
Absolutely yes - when the underlying securities decline in price. If you invest in an S&P 500 index fund and the stock market drops 25%, your fund loses approximately 25% of its value.
However, diversification through funds reduces your risk compared to individual stocks. A single company can go to zero, but a broad market index fund would require hundreds of companies to fail simultaneously, which is pretty unlikely to happen, or happens at times of global financial crisis.
Which has lower fees: ETF or mutual fund?
The cheapest option depends on the specific fund, not the structure (ETF or Mutual Fund).
While ETFs often have lower average expense ratios (around 0.15% for passive funds), many index mutual funds are just as cheap, or even free.
The Rule: Always compare the specific expense ratio of the funds you're looking at.
Should I choose ETFs or mutual funds for my 401(k)?
You typically won't have a choice. Most 401(k) plans only offer mutual funds, not ETFs, due to plan structure.
If your plan does offer a choice, focus on the cost. Choose the lowest-cost index fund available in your plan (ideally under 0.20%). Look for funds that track the total U.S. market or the S&P 500.
Simpler is better inside retirement accounts.
Are ETFs more tax-efficient than index mutual funds?
Yes - ETFs are generally more tax-efficient because they use a special mechanism to avoid selling stocks for cash when shares are redeemed (in-kind redemption), minimizing taxable capital gains for you. Over decades, this can save thousands in taxes.
Index Mutual Funds are much better than active funds but still generate more taxable events than ETFs.
How do I choose between an S&P 500 ETF and S&P 500 mutual fund?
Since both funds hold the exact same 500 stocks (Apple, Google, etc.) and have nearly identical, microscopic fees, their long-term performance will be the same. The decision is purely about how you prefer to buy them and what kind of account you use.
The S&P 500 Mutual Fund is usually best if you plan to invest automatically with a fixed dollar amount every month, or if you are investing through a 401(k) or IRA (where tax savings don't matter).
The S&P 500 ETF is usually better if you are investing in a regular (taxable) brokerage account (for its tax savings), or if you want to start with a small amount of money since there are no minimums.
What percentage of active funds beat index funds?
Overwhelmingly, no.
- The Data: Only about 22% of actively managed funds manage to beat simple, low-cost index funds over a 10-year period.
- The Core: For the core of the market (large U.S. stocks), the evidence is clear: passive index investing dominates.
- The Exception: Active managers sometimes perform better in very specific niche markets like bonds or emerging markets, where there is less information available to everyone.
Can I hold ETFs and mutual funds in the same portfolio?
Absolutely, yes. Most investors use both!
You might use ETFs in your taxable brokerage account (for tax efficiency) and mutual funds in your 401(k) (because that's what your employer offers).
The key is to avoid unnecessary overlap. Make sure you aren't buying an S&P 500 ETF and an S&P 500 mutual fund - you'd just be duplicating the same holdings. Check what's inside your funds to ensure you're getting the diversification you intend.
The Final Verdict: The Best Investment is...
In most cases ETFs win, as they are easy to start with a small amount of money, tax efficient, and give you the flexibility to trade anytime.
However, choose Mutual Funds if you are investing through a 401(k) or IRA (where tax efficiency doesn't matter) or if you want to set up effortless, automatic monthly deposits of a fixed dollar amount.
What matters now is taking action. Get started by checking out the Best Investment Accounts using our very own comparison tool!
Comments
Not logged in